Inside Ethiopia’s Endless War The Myth of Military Victory in Tigray

Inside Ethiopia’s Endless War The Myth of Military Victory in Tigray

The federal recapture of the Alula Aba Nega Airport outside Mekelle was supposed to signify a clean, decisive restoration of state authority. When federal troops and allied units pushed back Tigray People's Liberation Front (TPLF) fighters who had seized the tarmac weeks prior, the narrative from Addis Ababa mirrored the confident dispatches of November 2020. Order was being restored. Infrastructure was returning to federal oversight. A rebellious regional capital had been brought back to heel.

Yet anyone who has spent more than a week tracking the Horn of Africa understands a fundamental truth of modern counterinsurgency. Taking an asphalt strip or a municipal administration building is the easiest phase of an intractable political war. Holding the surrounding territory without the consent of the population is where campaigns unravel.

To understand why the latest cycle of fighting in Tigray refuses to follow a tidy script, one must look past the battlefield communiques and examine the structural decay of Ethiopia's political architecture.

The Collapse of the Original Coalition

When federal forces first entered Mekelle, the military campaign was backed by a formidable, if fragile, alignment of convenience. The central government under Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed had drawn support from regional Amhara forces hungry to reclaim contested land, Eritrean troops eager to neutralize a historic enemy, and regional authorities from Afar.

That alliance has completely dissolved.

The geopolitical map of East Africa has shifted beneath the feet of federal planners. Territorial disputes that were papered over during the Pretoria Agreement—most notably over Western Tigray—remain raw, festering sores. Amhara militias and Tigrayan fighters are caught in an endless loop of localized grievances, while regional cross-border dynamics involving Sudan and shifting regional alignments introduce volatile new variables. Addis Ababa is no longer fighting a localized insurrection with a united front of domestic partners; it is managing a multi-front security dilemma against the backdrop of broader interstate friction.

The Illusion of Urban Control

Modern military superiority is heavily weighted toward the center. Backed by expanded domestic production of reconnaissance and strike drones, federal forces command the skies. They can clear an airport, secure major arterial roads, and install a six-month caretaker administration intended to pave the way for future regional elections.

Air superiority, however, does not translate into administrative legitimacy.

Every urban center secured by federal bayonets immediately transforms into an isolated garrison requiring endless logistical support and constant protection against guerrilla infiltration. When supply routes are threatened and civilian populations remain deeply suspicious of federal mandates, the cost of occupation skyrockets. A government can deploy thousands of troops to guard public buildings in Mekelle, but if farmers in the countryside view those troops as an occupying force rather than protectors, the insurgency simply adapts, decentralizes, and waits.

The Cost of Broken Promises

The civilian toll of this recurring cycle is staggering, yet it is the political cost that truly threatens the longevity of the Ethiopian state. Displaced families who fled their homes years ago now watch their hopes of a permanent return evaporate as mortar fire and artillery blasts echo across the region once more.

When peace agreements fail to address the root causes of ethnic federalism, land ownership, and local autonomy, violence becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. Militias on all sides retain their arms because the alternative—surrendering weapons to a central authority they do not trust—is viewed as existential suicide.

The federal government has appointed a new regional leadership composed of ethnic Tigrayans to restore public services and shepherd the region toward participatory politics. It is a necessary administrative step. But an administrative appointment cannot substitute for a genuine political settlement. Until the fundamental question of how power is shared—and who truly holds sovereignty within the Ethiopian state—is addressed through honest negotiation rather than military coercion, every captured airport will merely be a waystation on the road to the next conflict.

The runway at Mekelle may be open, but the path forward remains entirely blocked.

Watch a report on the situation in Mekelle following the airport's recapture

This video provides on-the-ground footage and context regarding the security conditions in Mekelle after federal forces regained control of the airport.

OE

Owen Evans

A trusted voice in digital journalism, Owen Evans blends analytical rigor with an engaging narrative style to bring important stories to life.